Herein lies a problem I've been pondering lately:
On one hand, there are arguments for a true democracy (or, as properly defined, "direct democracy"). Direct Democracy was employed once effectively, in Athens, Greece. All free men were given the right to vote, and to sit on a council to debate and vote on important issues.
This Direct Democracy gave power to the lower and middle class, and took power from the top-heavy Oligarchy (read: aristocrats).
This was effective then, I believe, because the city-state of Athens wasn't nearly the size of any modern nations, and thus Athenian citizens were able to convene under one roof and vote on issues all at one time.
Obviously, with 300 million citizens (not just free white males, as in bygone days in Greece), convening under one roof might prove to be a bit impossible.
Not to mention, the ability to convene under one roof promoted the average Greek citizen into learning the issues and becoming a responsible and active player in politics.
Today, here's what we find... arm-chair political debaters that quote what they see on NBC or FOX news (which, if you are surprised to find out are owned and funded by strong-willed contributors to certain political parties, you might want to do a bit more research on your favorite "objective" news syndicates).
But other than arm-chair political debaters, the majority of the nation has no clue what is going on politically. I would venture to say that a small portion of the population is really in tune with current political situation and the possible solutions to problems at hand.
There are posts on this website that are right-- there is a certain "mob-rule" to the masses of the citizens of my country. Just go out on the town sometime- see what people are talking about... what's new reality show is on day-time television, what celebrity got a DUI or bashed whichever ethnic group, Paris Hilton, who's going to flash the cameras at the next Superbowl half-time show... even if it is about current-events or something that does matter... most of the time it's reiteration of what they've been told via some form of mass-communications.
The fact is that, most people follow blindly towards whatever their Party tells them is right, or what they see on television. For corporations with political mind, it must be like lambs to the slaughter. (COUNTERPOINT, there are people who care, and there are people who wants to lead this country to greatness: point of argument- this very website and others like it.)
If I am digressing, which I believe I am, I apologize. As a person who works in an emergency response field, i know how people react in large groups and when under stress... and it's not pretty, and it's not civilized, and it's not usually wise. Large groups of people DO need leaders. Hence the reason our Fore-Fathers established a democratic REPUBLIC.
So how can we balance this whole equation. How can we have the benefits of the power in the people's hands, of direct democracy, of getting rid of the evils of an oligarchy (which I would venture to say we have now). Certainly burueacrats and the major corporations that control them with campaign money have their bottom-line in mind and not our own interests (can't exactly blame them 100%... business is business and you gotta' make a dollar). Yet, the interests of the average citizen is what democracy is all about- not about just making the next big multi-national borderline monopoly/corporation richer.
BUT, how can we have the benefits of a republic- where the dangers of mob-rule are lessened, and we elect citizens who are better leaders than us to direct and lead us toward a common goal?
That is the question I put out there. Perhaps a better fusion of the two- direct deocracy, and republican governing, are the answer. We have some of that now, with referendums and such. Perhaps we ought to put them into action more? Or how about certain Scandinavian countries that employ a watchdog official, called an "Ombudsman." Is there a way to put more power into the people's hands without risking mob-rule?
I would like to hear anyone's ideas. |